Mixed Tumors, Breast Cancer Questions
Get Full Access Today It’s EASY and FREE!
Things you can do
More Questions
Find us on Facebook
Please help us spread the word about WhatNext so more people can find more relevant matches, gain more insight and feel a little less alone.
2nd opinion for treatment do i need it?
Asked by Lily on Saturday, March 18, 2017
2nd opinion for treatment do i need it?
21 Answers from the Community
Floridagirl6
I would recommend a second opinion.
- 1 Like
almost 4 years agoCarool
It depends. If you feel very confident in your first doctors and what they're recommending, why get a second opinion? If what they're recommending seems iffy or they have no protocols to offer, of course seek help elsewhere. I'd go, if possible, to a top cancer hospital. My cousin had IBC; went to MD Anderson - I see you're in Texas - of course, Texas is big, but I assume MD Anderson has satellites all over - and five years later, she's okay so far. I wish you the best of luck -
- 2 Like
almost 4 years agogeekling
With something as serious as cancer, I would and did get a second and independent opinion.
I actually counseled with 8 oncologists before I agreed to submit to any treatment. One of the people with whom I spoke was with MD Anderson.
In my case, he helped me to be patient and seek newer methodologies.
Best wishes.
- 1 Like
almost 4 years agoLynne-I-Am
A second opinion can be very informative about different courses of treatment , new possibilities, or reinforce what your current doctor recommends. I do not see a downside. Ultimately the choice for your medical care is yours.
- 1 Like
almost 4 years agoCarool
After reading these other responses, I revise my response. There is no downside. Actually, I did get a second opinion for my breast cancer, but it was because I didn't like the diagnosing breast surgeon or the hospital she was with. I'm very glad I switched. Had I first gone to the doctor and hospital (MSKCC) I ended up with, I would not have sought a second opinion.
- 1 Like
almost 4 years agoCoconut
I surely recommend it
- 1 Like
almost 4 years agoLily
All of you are awesome to encourage me. N
I will take uour advice. Looking at Mayo clinic...
- 2 Like
almost 4 years agoBoiseB
My friend got a second opinion and the two Dr. actually worked together and worked out a protocol that just fit her case and both Dr.s learned. Things have been happening so fast in cancer research that Dr.s can't keep up with them. Also you need to do a little research NOT googling. If you can go to a University library you and make use of their resources. The staff at most University libraries are happy to help members of the community access their data bases which include journals.
- 0 Like
almost 4 years agoJouska
I did not get a second opinion. However, I did have 3 doctors that I was working with, my general surgeon, my oncologist and my plastic surgeon. They were all very thorough and my general and my oncologist, especially, took time to discuss my opinions for treatment. No question was too large or too small for them. I am HER2+ and that narrows the options somewhat. However, anything that helps you make your best decisions is worth it, so if you are more comfortable with a second opinion, go for it.
- 0 Like
almost 4 years agoJudytjab
I agree with the others. I would get a second opinion. I did and went with my second opinion doctor and hospital. So glad that I did. Wishing you the best.
- 0 Like
almost 4 years agobarryboomer
No guarantee that the second Doc is any better than the first.
I hate cancer as there are so many variables that the patients head starts to swim.
I believe it is essential to research everything you can to help yourself...
It's just a mess......
- 0 Like
almost 4 years agoLiveWithCancer
It never hurts to get a second opinion. I would strongly consider it.
- 0 Like
almost 4 years agojoyuss59
you should always get a second opinion
- 0 Like
almost 4 years agojoyuss59
If for nothing else for your peace of mind
- 2 Like
almost 4 years agosarasmash
I just got my second opinion and I am glad I did. It reassured me that I am on the right track. It's nice to have an extra set of eyes looking at your process.
- 3 Like
almost 4 years agoLily
Thank u all so much for caring!!!
- 4 Like
almost 4 years agoMyahsMom
A second opinion is always a good thing. Two heads are better than one especially when it comes to cancer. It can tell you when you when you're on the right track. God Bless You!
- 0 Like
almost 4 years agoBuckeyeShelby
My hospital is not the big local cancer hospital. My cancer was discovered during a hernia repair. I sat in the surgeon's office for the initial consult just freaking out. I should be at the other hospital, the one that specializes in cancer treatment. Calmed myself down by reminding myself I could get a 2nd opinion. Then I met the surgeon. Who reached across his desk, shook my hand and said, "it's nice to meet you; I'm sorry you're here". What second opinion? I found my guy. Wasn't until after surgery that I discovered he's head of oncology at my hospital. I think it's more in your comfort w/the surgeon and staff -- that's the important thing. If you find your guy or gal in the first shot, great! If not, keep searching.
- 1 Like
almost 4 years agoBoiseB
I have had Dr.s ask for a second opinion, This was not in the cancer related but for my back injuries.
- 0 Like
almost 4 years agoBarbarainBham
It never hurts to have a second opinion. M.D. Anderson is the #1 cancer hospital, so seems meant to be.
- 0 Like
almost 4 years agomimistewart
i did not get a second opinion. i instantly liked my doctor and felt confident with him and his group. sometimes the office people are a little trying but i think they are working very hard and get overwhelmed but so far so good......i like all to be in a sequence(very anal) haha and that is frustrating for me.....i guess its how you feel in your heart.good luck
- 1 Like
almost 4 years agoHelp the community by answering this question:
Read and answer more mixed tumors, breast cancer questions. Also, don't forget to check out our Mixed Tumors, Breast Cancer page.